STD 105: Process Groups as an
Instructional Medium for Re-entry Women
at Paul D Camp Community College

by Elizabeth Creamer, Molly Duggin, and Ronald Kidd

from Inquiry, Volume 4, Number 2, Fall 1999, 19-25

© Copyright 1999 Virginia Community College System

Return to Volume 4, Number 2


Abstract
An effective team-based, group-oriented personal development from a woman's perspective course (STD 105) explores the effects of several issues on the re-entry woman: the role that society and culture play in influencing women’s vocational choices; women’s role; the economic necessity of work; stress; and relationships. A team-based approach provides a support system to help re-entry students better handle these issues, thus increasing their chances of success as well as their retention in college.

 

Women frequently enter college juggling multiple roles: caretaker, daughter, mother, spouse/lover, student, employee, business owner, and community volunteer. Societal attitudes about women have shaped their perceptions about themselves and their roles, sometimes impeding their personal and career successes. Entering (or re-entering) college, then, may create conflicts as women struggle to balance multiple roles while trying to meet externally or internally imposed demands of being a successful mother, successful community volunteer, and successful career woman, oftentimes without an adequate support system (Bradley 1990). Many of these "jugglers," unfortunately, simply drop the educational ball. Viewing themselves as without support, they may stop attending classes (not always withdrawing from them first) or start letting their educational and career goals fade, sometimes dropping out and re-entering college as many as three or four times.

At Paul D. Camp Community College (PDCC) we faced the question of how as educators and couselors we could help these students reach their education and career goals without arbitrarily insisting on their primacy in relation to family or other relationships. Although the community college STD 100 Orientation class was designed to assist students in their college transition, re-entry students did not always receive from this class what they needed to succeed. Thus, a team-based, group-oriented "Personal Development from a Woman’s Perspective" (STD 105) course was designed to better suit the re-entry women’s needs than a class designed for the more traditional community college student.

According to VCCS 1998 Master Course List, STD 105 - does the following:

addresses the psychological and educational adjustment needs of the female college student. . . covers three segments: personal development, career education, and study skills. . . emphasizes the special needs of the re-entry woman. . . provides education and support for the individual.

In March 1998, Paul D Camp Community College’s Smithfield Center offered its first STD 105 class but with a few additions to the course description. First, we team-teach the course, using a male-female instructional team. Second, we begin with a weekend-long intensive class meeting of twelve hours, interrupted only by a few hours of sleep, and followed by evening meetings scheduled for four consecutive weeks. We have also added team-building activities to the course, along with a group component that provides STD 105 students with many of the tools they need for success, not only in education, but in career and family.

Change research issues suggest that appropriate content upon which to focus group processes might include care-taking roles, careers, relationships, depression, sexuality, spirituality, and life transitions. Support seemed an effective way to maintain instruction gains after the end of the course. Effects of isolation were seen as loss of faith and loss of a sense of achievement. All of these preceding concerns prompted the choice of process groups as an instructional medium for STD 105. From an administrative perspective, issues of student recruitment, retention, public relations, and student services were met through the design and implementation of the course.

Group activities in STD 105 include group-developed graphic displays, role-plays, visualization, relaxation exercises, and group interaction regarding many of the topics explored in the large group. Members learn self-expression, communication skills, and develop a renewed perspective on their own adulthood. They experience the legitimacy of their own emotions, including pleasure and pain, and learn ways of discharging such emotions (Nadeau, 1984; Warren 1984). Role presentations, replays, role reversals, role taking, and self-preservation work well (cf., Blatner and Blatner, 1988). Closing activities used on the last night of a class seem to cement students’ sense of accomplishment during the transitional time marked by the course (Parker and Horton, 1995).

As in any change activity, some students initially experience resistance to the class. However, the group process brings about a sense of trust through group identification, a sense of reciprocity with other group members, self-disclosure, positive feedback, and group cohesion. The inevitable group conflicts provide opportunities to deal with differences of opinions, anger, and jealousy. Attitudes toward self and toward others change. Likelihood of self-expression also changes. One’s sense of a private self is less isolated and cut off from the world of others than is generally true prior to the group process (cf., Blatner and Blatner, 1988; Butler and Wintram, 1991; Nadeau, 1984; Russell, 1984 and Warren, 1984).

Enthusiasm for the course format and team-teaching among students in the course sections quickly spread throughout the Center’s student body. Consequently, a variety of other demographically targeted Student Development and academic courses--each incorporating the weekend-intensive, team-teaching format--were designed and implemented at the Center with the result that enrollments for some courses, which had never before attracted sufficient enrollment to "make" at the Center, exceeded 30 students.

Since January 1998, Paul D Camp Community College’s Smithfield Center Full-Time Equivalent enrollment has increased 140% (from 50 FTE in Fall ’97 to 120 FTE in both Fall ’98 and Spring ’99). The number of courses "making" at the Center increased 146% during the same period, and local scholarship support for new course offerings and programs, such as STD 105, has increased 2000%. New program development at the Center has emanated from shared values first clarified by STD 105; such programs include a paid internship program for young college students at risk for retention that has partnered us with local schools and the school district. Creative scheduling—such as three credits in three weekends courses, Saturday classes, and one credit "sampler" courses—have garnered enthusiastic participation from the current student body and attracted interest and enrollment even from individuals residing outside the college’s service area. Classes created and offered in partnership with local businesses and organizations have also led to expansion in enrollment.

If what the Smithfield Center is doing is "right," as is suggested by increased student enrollment and improved student retention, it is a result of what we, as a team, first learned through the development and implementation of STD 105. A student-centered educational institution with a holistic approach to learning and counseling has emerged and is fostered at the Center. And, just as the students in STD 105 come to enjoy the sense of community that develops in the process groups in the course, so the Center has come to experience itself as part of its community and to participate in the processes of the community. In these corresponding processes, social skills improve, a sense of security develops, and a sense of value of self and others increases in the Center’s faculty and staff, as well as in its students. Just as the students come to hold out for themselves the prospect of success, so the Center has come to experience as sense of success and satisfaction beyond what, 18 months ago, we would ever have expected.


Student Voices From STD 105

by Ronald V. Kidd, Ph.D.

What follows are the voices of students who have shared the experience of STD 195.

References

Blatner, A. and Blatner, A. (1988). Foundations of psychodrama: History, theory, and practice. 3rd edition. New York: Springer.

Bradley, L.J. (1990). Counseling midlife career changes. Garrett Park, MD: Garrett Park Park.

Brehony, K.A. (1987). Self-help groups with agoraphobic women. In C.M. Brody (Ed.), Women’s therapy groups: Paradigms of feminist treatment. (82-94). New York: Springer.

Burden, D.S. and N. Gottlieb. (1987). Women’s socialization and feminist groups. In C. M. Brody (Ed.) Women’s therapy groups: Paradigms of feminist treatment. (24-39). New York: Springer.

Butler, S. and C. Wintram. (1991). Feminist groupwork. Newbury Park, CA: Sage

Cammaert, L.P. and C.C. Larsen (1988). Feminist frameworks of psychotherapy. In M.A. Dutton-Douglas and L.E.A. Walker (Eds.) Feminist psychotherapies:Integration of therapeutic and feminist systems. Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 12-36.

Chaplin, J. (1988). Feminist counseling in action. Thousand Oaks, CA.: Sage.

Curtis, S. (1978). Introduction to Chapter II. Contemporary approaches to helping women. In E.T. Nickerson, O.M. Espin, R.S. Dorn, and S. Curtis (Eds.) Helping women: Readings in the psychology and counseling of women.Washington, DC: University Press of America, 93-96.

Dutton-Douglas, M.A. and L.E. Walker (1988). Introduction to feminist therapies. In M. A. Dutton-Douglas and L.E. Walker (Eds.) Feminist psychotherapies: integration of therapeutic and feminist systems. Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 3-11.

Johnson, M. (1987). "Feminist therapy in groups: A decade of change. In C.M. Brody (Ed.). Women’s therapy groups: Paradigms of feminist treatment. New York: Springer, 13-23.

Nadeau, R. (1984). Using the visual arts to expand personal creativity. In B.Warren (Ed.) Using the creative arts in therapy. Cambridge, MA: Brookline Books, 61-86.

Parker, R. J. and H.S. Horton, Jr. (1995). Blessing ourselves and others: Rituals toEnhance well-being and strengthen relationships. Virginia Counselors Journal. 23:5061.

Rawlings, E.I. and D.L.R. Graham. (1988). Feminist therapy with divorced, single, female parents. In M.A. Dutton-Douglas and L.E.A. Walker (Eds.) Feministpsychotherapies: Integration of therapeutic and feminist systems. Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 156-185.

Rothberg, B.R. and V. Ubell (1987). Feminism and systems theory: Its impact on lesbian and heterosexual couples. In C.M. Brody (Ed.) Women’s therapy groups: Paradigms of feminist treatment. (132-144). New York: Springer, 132-144.

Russell, M.N. (1984). Skills in counseling women: The feminist approach. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.

Yalom, I.D. (1985). The theory and practice of group psychotherapy. 3rd ed. New York: Basic Books.


M. Elizabeth Creamer is the Academic Program Coordinator for the Smithfield Center of Paul D Camp Community College in Smithfield, Virginia. She also works as an adjunct instructor of English.

Molly H. Duggan is Coordinator of Education for Independence at the Franklin Campus of Paul D Camp Community College and also works as an adjunct instructor of student development and English.

Ronald V. Kidd, Ph.D., is an adjunct instructor of psychology, English, and student development and an academic advisor at the Smithfield Center of Paul D Camp Community College.